Torsion and Detorsion in Gastropoda

Definition:

Torsion (twisting) is the rotation of visceral organs in anticlockwise direction through an angle of 180° on the rest of the body during larval development. The phenomenon takes place in the free-swimming (veliger) larva of gastropods and converts the symmetrical larva into an asym­metrical adult.

Contraction of the larval retractor mus­cles and differential growth are possibly responsible for such rotation (Fig. 16.71 A, B, C). Entire rotation results within few min­utes. Asymmetry is encountered at the early stage in Veliger larva where the mesodermal bands develop asymmetrically. The meso­dermal band on the right side is larger than its left counterpart.

The right band is com­posed of five mesoderm cells which elongate to form muscle cells. With the transforma­tion of the muscle cells the visceral hump is displaced to the left side.

These cells on the right side converge and transform into the larval retractor muscles. The muscle cells are absent on the left side. Torsion of the visceral hump commences as soon as the larval muscle cells attain the power of contraction (Fig. 16.71 A, B, C).

Conditions before Torsion:

1. The mantle cavity is situated at the posterior side containing the pallial complex.

2. The ctenidia and two nephridiopores are located posteriorly.

3. The alimentary canal is straight with the mouth at the anterior side and anus at the posterior side.

4. The auricles are placed behind the ventricle.

5. The nervous system is bilaterally sym­metrical.

6. Firstly, the embryo is bilaterally sym­metrical in the veliger stage when foot and a planospiral shell are formed first in this stage.

Remarks:

Torsion is not the coiling of the shell and all the evidences indicate that the shell evolved before torsion.

How Torsion Occurs:

1. The morphological phenomenon of bending on the ventral side which takes place in an antero-posterior sagittal plane about a transverse axis of the animal results.

(a) Firstly, the displacement of the mantle cavity towards the right side and then to the anterior end of the body but the head and foot remain fixed (Fig, 16.72).

(b) The looping of the digestive tract and approximation of mouth and anus take place.

(c) The original saucer-shaped visceral mass and the shell become cone- shaped and finally become spi­rally coiled.

2. Simultaneous coiling up of these struc­tures results in an exogastric coil.

3. Ventral portion of the visceral mass and mantle rotate about 180° or little more.

4. Twisting of dorsal mass occurs in such a manner that organs such as right gill and right auricle remain and corre­sponding parts on the left side are often lost.

5. During the completion of metamor­phosis there is a lateral torsion subse­quent to primitive ventral plexus with the result that the original coil of the visceral sac and the shell which was originally dorsal or exogastric becomes ventral or endogastric. So the lateral torsion leads to the attainment of con­dition of gastropods following certain changes in original organisation.

Cause and Significance of Lateral Torsion:

1. Lateral torsion is due to arrested growth of one side and active expan­sion of the other. Generally the growth of the right side becomes retarded so that the mantle cavity and pallial com­plex gradually pass down to the right side and to the anterior side on ac­count of the better growth of visceral mass towards the left.

2. This is necessary for protection, com­pactness and provision for continuous growth. This is the response with ne­cessity in life of animal for best adaption.

Effect of Torsion and Shuttling of Pallial Complex:

1. Displacement of mantle cavity:

The mantle cavity was originally pos­terior in position but after torsion the mantle cavity opens just behind the head and its associated parts shifted forward.

2. Changes in relative position:

Before torsion the anus and ctenidia are pointed backwards and auricles are situated behind the ventricle. After torsion the anus and ctenidia come forward and the auricles come to lie in front of ventricle.

3. Twisting of alimentary canal:

The alimentary canal which was pri­marily straight is twisted in the form of a loop and approximation of mouth and anus takes place.

4. Origin of chiastoneury:

Crossing of the pleuro-visceral con­nectives is due to the fact that the pallial complex must have changed its position from the posterior to the an­terior part of the body arid become twisted in the form of 8. The right connective with its parietal ganglion passes over the intestine called the supraintestinal and the left connective passes below the intestine called the infraintestinal.

5. Endogastric coil:

The coil of visceral sac which was primarily dorsal or exogastric becomes ventral or endogastric after torsion. The coiling of the shell is not associ­ated with the torsion and was a sepa­rate evolutionary event and the shell remained a symmetrical spiral.

6. Loss of symmetry:

It is due to displacement of anus to­wards right side of the mantle cavity and loss or reduction of paired parts of the primitively left or topographi­cally right side.

In majority of the gastropods torsion, as already stated, is resulted in two stages, viz., Stage-I and Stage-II:

Stage-I:

The contraction of the larval retractor muscles account for 90° of the rota­tion of the visceral hump. This process usu­ally lasts for only a few hours. At the end of Stage-I, the mantle cavity (which was ini­tially situated ventrally and posteriorly) comes on the right side with the foot project­ing on the left side.

Stage-II:

The rest of the torsion is the result of differential growth and is usually longer in duration. Actual mechanism of torsion in gastropods is not proper y known and it is difficult to give a generalised ac­count of torsion in gastropods.

However, Thomson (1958) distinguished five possible ways by which torsion has resulted in gas­tropods:

They are:

(a) 180° rotation of visceral hump is achieved by muscular contraction alone. This mechanism is seen in Acmaea and is regarded to be the original way of torsion.

(b) The commonest way of torsion (180°) as encountered in Haliotis, Patella, etc., is achieved in two subsequent stages.

(i) The initial 90° rotation is caused by the contraction of the larval retractor muscle and

(ii) The remaining 90° is effected by differential growth. The first phase occurs at a faster rate, while the next phase is slower.

(c) In some gastropods as exemplified by Vivipara, complete (180°) rotation is achieved exclusively by growth proc­esses.

(d) In Aplysia, torsion is resulted by dif­ferential growth and the change in position of anus is halted at a region appropriate to the adult stage.

(e) In Adalaria, torsion of the viscero­pallium is not recognisable. The dif­ferent organs appear as in the post- torsional position.

Whatever be the cause of torsion in gas­tropods, a post-torsional larva possesses an anteriorly placed mantle cavity and all the developing organs are severely affected.

With the completion of torsion many organ sys­tems (e.g., Pallial organs, nervous system) become greatly affected. Formation of loop and crossing of pleuroparietal connectives are a common occurrence in the nervous sys­tem in gastropods, especially protobranchia.

Views on the Significance of Torsion in Gastropods:

Torsion is a characteristic feature of gas­tropods. The significance of such torsion in gastropods is not clear. Several contrasting views are extant on this issue.

They are:

(a) Garstang’s view:

Garstang (1928) advocated that torsion is an adaptive feature and useful to the larvae (veliger larva) for protection of soft parts against enemies but of little direct use to the adult.

He suggested that before torsion the untwisted larva swimming the sea was sub­jected as an easy prey to its predators be­cause the mantle cavity was at the posterior position and there is no place into which delicate head and velum can be withdrawn at the time of danger so it is disadvanta­geous to the larval life.

But after torsion the mantle cavity is brought around the anterior end of the larva which provides the space for head and velum and the larva gives the greater protection of the head and associated structures. At danger the larva is able to withdraw its head and velum into the man­tle cavity. Then the beating of cilia stops and the larva falls to the sea bottom. In this way they avoid the predators.

This view is widely supported by Yonge (1947), Barnes (1980), Ruppert and Barnes (1994) and Anderson (1998). But the recent experiment by Pennigton and Chia (1985) does not support Garstang’s view.

Objections:

The theory was criticised for several rea­sons such as:

1. There are many pelagic larvae of lamellidens which are not twisted but still survive in pelagic larval life.

2. The cilia of some gastropods are un­der nervous control and these could be stopped by simpler means than withdrawing them into the mantle cavity.

3. In Haliotis the shell rotates in two phases – firstly through 90° and sec­ondly then through 180° but the ani­mal is only pelagic at the first stage while the head is unable to retract into the mantle cavity. The larva does not complete its torsion (180°) till it has settled in the bottom.

(b) C.M. Yonge’s theory (1947):

1. Primitive Gastropods were not twisted and the gills were attached posteriorly inside the mantle cavity. The cilia of the gills draw the respiratory current from behind the mantle which is in opposite direction of the current pro­duced by the locomotion of the animal and the weak current of the sea itself, thus producing disadvantage in respi­ration and locomotion.

2. If the animal once twists all the cur­rents would follow in the same direc­tion, thus aid the flushing of mantle cavity with freshwater and thus tor­sion becomes advantageous for ventilation of mantle cavity.

3. The twist brings the anus anterior, so there is some chance of interaction between the discharged faecal matter and respiratory current.

To avoid this, at least three adaptations are found:

(a) Shell develops a fold or series of folds. The anus retracted and res­piratory currents sweep over the gills, e.g., Haliotis.

(b) One of the gills and its associated auricles are lost, so that the respi­ratory current sweeps laterally through the mantle cavity.

(c) Gills are either reduced or lost. The respiratory surface in the mantle cavity which in some cases develops pallial gills, e.g., Patella.

(c) Morton’s view:

Morton (1958) emphasises the importance of anterior location of mantle cavity both in larval and adult molluscs. The anteriorly placed mantle cavity housing the head with sense organs, respiratory structures, etc. in adult add positive advantage to test the water and also to come in intimate contact for gaseous exchange with the oncoming water respectively.

(d) Ghiselin’s view (1966):

According to him, the primitive gastro­pods developed a conical shell on the dorsal surface for protection instead of shield-like shell. To maintain the balance of body the shell of the gastropods prolonged anteriorly.

But for the crawling purpose it was disad­vantageous bearing such anteriorly pro­longed shell. The shell containing anterior- prolonged side rotated into the posterior through 180° during torsion. So it has be­come advantageous in the adult stage.

Stasek (1972) and Purchon (1977) have also supported that torsion is advantageous during adult stage.

Coiling:

The ability of withdrawal of the head-foot complex into the anterior mantle cavity due to torsion increases the efficiency in locomotion, feeding and sensory func­tion in gastropods. The head-foot complex retains its bilateral symmetry. The visceral hump together with the protecting shell becomes coiled to economies the volume.

Detorsion:

Acquisition of secondary symmetry ob­served in some Opisthobranch Gastropod is regarded as the result of detorsion. The distortion means the reversion to the changes that have occurred during torsion. As a result of detorsion the pallial complex travels towards the posterior end along the right side.

The ctenidia are pointed backwards and the auricles come behind the ventricle. The vis­ceral loop becomes untwisted and symmetri­cal. In this way a secondary external symme­try is established again. Detorsion is always associated with the loss of shell and the liberation of gills (ctenidia) from their en­closing case.

The gills become exposed and subjected to external current. Different gra­dations of detorsions are encountered in the different members of opisthobranchs. In Acteon and Bulla detorsion is partial, and complete detorsion is observed in Aplysia. In some nudibranchs (e.g., Doris, Apolidia, etc.), the shell and mantle cavity are absent and the body becomes secondarily bilaterally symmetrical.